Claims and Payments ASI Claims: 866-274-8765 Payments: 866-274-8765 American Modern Claims: 800-375-2075 Payments: 800-543-2644 CNA Claims: 877-262-2727 Payments: 800-331-6053 Dairyland Claims: 800-542-6246 Payments: 800-542-6246 Foremost Claims: 800-527-3907 Payments: 888-888-0080 Farmers Claims: 800-435-7764 Payments: 888-327-6335 Grundy Insurance Claims: 888-647-8639 Option 3 Payments: See Website Geovera Claims: 800-859-8734 Payments: 800-324-6020 Hagerty Claims: 877-922-9701 Payments: 888-220-9565 JC Taylor Claims: 800-345-8290 Payments: 800-345-8290 Mapfre Claims: 877-627-3731 Payments: 877-627-3731 National General Claims: 800-468-3466 Payments: 877-468-3466 Nationwide Claims: 800-421-3535 Payments: 888-891-0267 Palomar Claims: 619-567-5290 Payments PEMCO Claims: 800-467-3626 Payments: 800-467-3626 Progressive Claims: 800-776-4737: Option 1 Payments: 800-776-4737: Option Safeco Claims: 800-332-3226 Payments: 800-332-3226 Travelers Claims: 800-252-4633 Payments:800-842-5075